Frozen: A sermon delivered by Disney Pixar
Loved
and reviewed by Rev. Peter T. Atkinson
December
16, 2013
The roses out on the roof were in
full bloom, and peeped in at the window; and there stood the little chairs, on
which they had sat when children; and Kay and Gerda seated themselves each on
their own chair, and held each other by the hand, while the cold empty grandeur
of the Snow Queen’s palace vanished from their memories like a painful dream.
The grandmother sat in God’s bright sunshine, and she read aloud from the
Bible, “Except ye become as little children, ye shall in no wise enter into the
kingdom of God.” And Kay and Gerda looked into each other’s eyes, and all at
once understood the words of the old song,
“Roses bloom and cease to be,
But we shall the Christ-child see.”
But we shall the Christ-child see.”
And they both sat there, grown
up, yet children at heart; and it was summer,—warm, beautiful summer. ~ Hans
Christian Andersen from “The Snow Queen”
Last
year, I went to see Les Miserables in
the theater and thought it moving, and so I wrote a collection of my thoughts
on it, and many of you were interested. I have been so inspired again; this
time in a much more unexpected place: a Disney Princess movie. In my sermon
this past Sunday, I said that Frozen is
the best Christmas Sermon I have heard this year. It is that, and certainly
more, here is why.
Perhaps
it shouldn’t be a surprise because a few years ago Tangled also had a very powerful and important message for us today
(honestly princess movies overall get a bad rap for spreading shallow damsel in
distress themes, a view caused by much too short-sighted, close-minded, agenda-driven
viewers). Like Tangled, Frozen tackles the dangers of fear, and
the way fear keeps us caged, rather than free, never becoming who we were made
to be, who the world very much needs us to be.
I
am going to deal with the plot here, so I should issue a spoiler alert, so at
least you’ll be warned to stop reading. . .
Frozen is basically the story of two
sisters, the princesses of Arendelle, Anna and Elsa, and one of them (Elsa) is
born with the magical power to freeze things. She can make ice, snow, beautiful
sculptures of ice, basically out of thin air, and of course a snowman named
Olaf, but she does not know how to control her power. At a young age, she
accidentally injures her sister, Anna, by hitting her with her “ice blast.” It
hits her head and not her heart, so she is not killed. The unconscious Anna is
taken to trolls who save her, and they can save her because the freezing hit
her head and not her heart. An important theme is introduced here that a head
is much easier to change than a heart, a subtle foreshadowing of the later
important dichotomy between head love (superficial, flimsy, transient) and
heart love (real, powerful, eternal).
The
trolls then warn Elsa’s parents that “fear” is the greatest danger, that within
Elsa there is great power, but fear could cause a very dreadful future for them
and the kingdom. They take “fear” to mean the way that people would react to
Elsa’s power, being afraid of her, so they keep it all a secret, locking her
away, even from Anna. Their parents, in the mean time, tragically die at sea,
leaving Elsa to be queen. All this back story drags a bit, but effectively so,
because their, Anna and Elsa’s, lives drag as well, isolated from each other
and the world. This isolation is shown by Anna singing, “Do You Want to Build a
Snowman?,” to the closed door of Elsa’s room. Anna completely is shut out, and
doesn’t know why.
The
doors and gates must then be opened for Elsa’s coronation as queen. The doors,
which have been closed for many years, will now be open, much symbolism there
of Elsa’s confinement coming to a close. . . is she ready? Is she in control?
The song, “For the First Time in Forever”
seeks to capture the moods at that moment of the two sisters in counterpoint. The
song opens with Anna, who is excited. She cannot wait for her world to change,
she sings lines like:
The window is open, so's that
door
I didn't know they did that anymore
I didn't know they did that anymore
and
For years I've roamed these empty
halls
Why have a ballroom with no balls? (a great subtle reminder of the fear motif, go Disney)
Why have a ballroom with no balls? (a great subtle reminder of the fear motif, go Disney)
and
There'll be actual real live
people
It'll be totally strange
But wow, am I so ready for this change
'Cause for the first time in forever
There'll be music, there'll be light
For the first time in forever
I'll be dancing through the night
It'll be totally strange
But wow, am I so ready for this change
'Cause for the first time in forever
There'll be music, there'll be light
For the first time in forever
I'll be dancing through the night
She
is a naïve, excited, clumsy, dreamy, teenage girl, ready for anything, ready
for love. She is starved for contact with people, and is certainly ready to
fall in love at first sight. She is everything the Disney princesses get
accused of being, and it’s great because she is going to meet the world, and
it’s not going to be what she expects. It’s cruel, but it doesn’t kill her,
beat her or destroy her, rather it teaches her about what real love is, and
what real life is, offering a great look at the reason why humans need
struggle.
Elsa,
on the other hand, is nervous that she will hurt people with the magic she has
been practicing for years how to conceal. She is afraid of the way people will
react. She wears gloves, is very concealed, she sings:
Don't let them in, don't let them
see
Be the good girl you always have to be
Conceal, don't feel, put on a show
Make one wrong move and everyone will know
Be the good girl you always have to be
Conceal, don't feel, put on a show
Make one wrong move and everyone will know
It’s
that “Conceal, don’t feel, put on a show” line that is so powerful, and is at
the core of the power of the movie. She has magic within her, magic that only
she possesses, magic that the world desperately needs, but she must keep it
within because she is afraid how the world will react. She lives in fear of
fear. Elsa is just like so many of the boys I teach, for whatever reason they
are afraid of their powers. For Elsa it’s instilled in her by her parents. That
may just be true for the boys, too, but I think it’s deeper than that.
For
me, this is what Sin is: our misunderstanding of who and what we are. Since we
don’t know who we are, we are fearful of being what we are. It’s easier to just
go through the motions. It’s safer, but it isolates us, traps us, imprisoning
us in these invisible walls. For Elsa it’s a literal wall, and literal gloves,
but for us it is so much more. It is everything we build to shelter ourselves
from danger, whether people or experience, all to protect our lives, but it has
the counter effect; it makes us not ever live.
Sin
is, in my definition, based on my own exegesis of The Bible, faith, history,
and life around me, believing the lie, that God doesn’t make the world,
including us, including everything around us, and including the ways our world
works. . . sometimes referred to but not limited to natural law. It is not
believing, therefore, that the world is in order, and that, that order is
working itself out within God’s creation for Good. One of the symptoms of that
disease, probably the most diabolical, is that we do not see ourselves and each
other as important, purposed, magic filled (talented), pieces of that glorious
order. We choose instead to live in the belief that we do not matter, and
instead “put on a show” and call it life.
Elsa
is a great narrative example of this fact. It’s not completely her fault alone,
rather she is just born within a system that produces it. Her parents instill
it in her, as does everyone else she meets. It’s a literal rendering of how
Original Sin works, not in some metaphysical spiritual sense, but in a real
life, diseased and broken world sense, self perpetuating, all encompassing,
invisible because it is all we know.
So
the doors open, and the “tale of two sisters” continues running parallel. I
want to focus on Elsa first, and then show Anna, but I will mention now how
Anna becomes the impetus for Elsa’s actions.
Anna
falls in “love at first sight” in typical predictable princess fashion. She
meets the handsome prince, Mr. Perfect, dreamy and wonderful, and they decide
they want to get married. It happens in song (of course), “Love is an Open
Door” (No it’s not, we’ll get to that later):
Hans: Can I say something crazy?
Will you marry me?
Anna: Can I say something even crazier? Yes!
Anna: Can I say something even crazier? Yes!
And
so they go to Elsa to ask for her blessing. Elsa, who his working very hard to
successfully hide her feelings, still concealing, still gloved, of course
responsibly says, “No.” She argues with Anna, and slowly loses control of
everything she has been keeping inside. The ice begins to flow from her, in all
directions. People are afraid, and they call her a monster. She flees, thinking
that she is protecting them all from the monster within herself, but she sets
off in the process a winter storm in the middle of the summer.
We
have come to the most moving and inspired moment in the movie. It is the
perfect blend of visual, musical, and lyrical all captured in four glorious
minutes. Elsa is now free. She is out of the room. She can use her powers. She
is safe from hurting anyone (so she thinks). She is still isolated, but no
longer repressing her powers and her emotions, she lets them all go, and sings
“Let it Go.”
There is obvious power in the song. When she sings
“let it go” each time, she creates so many beautiful, no breath-taking pieces
of visual art. She makes a magnificent castle, within which she will again
close herself, but also she makes a little snowman, a subconscious homage to
the relationship she used to have with Anna. . . relationship: the very thing
she doesn’t know she really needs.
But
lyrically what is most impressive is the seamless connection of three symbolic
images: cold, freedom, and isolation. The cold mirrors her power, but also
reflects the freeze of her emotions and her coldness towards the rest of the
world. The freedom is the outpouring of those emotions, now finally set free.
The isolation, so subtly woven, shows that she, though free, is still alone,
concealed, constricted, and so her freedom is only an illusion. Her ice palace,
though bigger and certainly more beautiful and grand, is no different from her
room. The same fear that kept her imprisoned in Arendelle has her imprisoned
still. The subtle images of this isolation foreshadow the fact that her freedom
is faulty, an illusion, and therefore cannot not be sustainable.
Look
at these examples:
Don’t let them in, don’t let them
see
Be the good girl you always have to be
Conceal, don’t feel, don’t let them know
Well now they know
Be the good girl you always have to be
Conceal, don’t feel, don’t let them know
Well now they know
The
“conceal, don’t feel” lines return; she thinks that the problem with her magic
was that it had to be hidden from people, that now since “they know,” she is
free to let her powers loose to find her true potential. The problem is that
they may know, but they don’t understand, so there is still a division between
her and them. She is still isolated. She has a gift, but keeps it to herself.
The world knows she has it, but has called her a monster and sent her away.
Again it’s not all her fault, but the fault of a world that is very much broken
by the ignorance I’ve called Sin. She is a part of it, too, of course, with her
own piece of blame in need of something to save her (It's coming. . . ).
The
chorus explodes:
Let it
go, let it go
Can’t hold it back anymore
Let it go, let it go
Turn away and slam the door
I don’t care what they’re going to say
Let the storm rage on
The cold never bothered me anyway.
Can’t hold it back anymore
Let it go, let it go
Turn away and slam the door
I don’t care what they’re going to say
Let the storm rage on
The cold never bothered me anyway.
There
is freedom there, but she still “turns away” and “slam[s] the door.” The last
line of the chorus is perfect. “The cold never bothered me anyway. . .” It’s
about her, and here in this world she can make it whatever she likes. She can
be herself now. She can make the world the way she wants it. She can create her
own beauty, and the rest of the world be damned.
It’s time to see what I can do
To test the limits and break through
No right, no wrong, no rules for me,
I’m free
To test the limits and break through
No right, no wrong, no rules for me,
I’m free
Now that she is set free, in her mind, she can do
whatever she wants, but it is all very much limited within the confines of the world she has
created. The connections to us are mind blowing. We each create worlds for
ourselves, where we can be free. It is our world of dishonesty. We do it every
time we tell a lie. We tell lies to both ourselves and others, creating worlds
that are free, maybe, but not at all real. We create a reality where we can be
a little bit more free, but then we are bound by that lie, isolated,
disconnected, a free self, but for what?
Here we are. We have arrived at the truth, have
uncovered our purpose, the truth about God’s world, we ignore when we believe
the lie instead of that truth. Here we see that the purpose of life is love.
The purpose for our gifts is to share them. The goodness of God’s creation is
made by love and revolves completely around love. We can’t actualize it in a
castle of our own creation, but instead out in the messy world of conflicting
opinions and views. . . but within that struggle, within that mess, is God’s
amazingly wonderful creation: the one that he calls “good.”
I’m
never going back
The past is in the past. . .
The past is in the past. . .
. . . That
perfect girl is gone
She
sings it, but it just isn’t true. We never can escape from ourselves. We own
our lives, every moment, and to think otherwise perpetuates the lie. The beauty
though, is that love, accepts us with all the wrinkles, all the mistakes, all
the powers that we are ashamed of, because they are all a part of us, and
therefore a part of God’s perfect creation. These truths are all shown
gloriously at the end of the movie.
So
now to Anna. . .
We
left Anna asking her sister for permission to marry the man she just met, Hans.
They have just sung a song together called “Love is an Open Door,” to which I
briefly referred earlier. In this song, they both finish each other’s
sentences, stumbling clumsily into a simple sweet version of love in true
Disney fashion, but the beauty of the song is that it’s all a farce, an
illusion, a joke, and importantly not real. The song is purposefully silly
because it is describing love that is silly. It proves that all love is not
love. It is a masterfully done paradoxical satire on immature illusions of
love. It’s filled with tongue in cheek lines:
Hans: I mean it's crazy
Anna: What?
Hans: We finish each other's
Anna: Sandwiches
Hans: That's what I was gonna say!
Anna: What?
Hans: We finish each other's
Anna: Sandwiches
Hans: That's what I was gonna say!
In
the cloud of this type of love, it doesn’t matter about truth. The emotion of it
is all that matters. We’ll soon know, too that Hans is not genuine. He is
playing Anna, so he can use her to become ruler. So, rather than finishing
“sentences” like we’d expect, he’s quick to say that “sandwiches” is what he
had in mind. It is subtle, but this song is hardly Romeo and Juliet speaking a
perfect sonnet together during their first encounter in Act 1 of Romeo and
Juliet. But she is looking for that R & J storybook type love, and it isn’t
the type love that is the central point of Frozen’s witness (In Shakespeare's
defense, his play also does not consider the love between Romeo and Juliet real
at this point either. It is only Act 1 of course).
So
they ask to get married, Elsa refuses, her side of the story begins, with her
“Letting it Go” up on the north mountain, but for Anna and the rest of
Arendelle, Elsa’s explosion and departure has left them buried in a perpetual
winter. Anna’s adventure begins. She tries to restore summer by going to Elsa, getting
her to simply “reverse the spell.” Anna is sure that Elsa will do so because
she is the loving sister Anna remembers from childhood underneath this new Snow
Queen identity.
So
she heads out of town, leaving Hans in charge, not planning for much of a trip,
still in her party dress. She soon realizes the trek will be harder than she
had thought. She is befriended by Christophe and his Reindeer, Sven. They are
not the picture of prince charming and his noble steed, but instead are big
burly clumsy, unsophisticated and unkempt, but loyal, loving, creative,
genuine, and sensitive. They help each other get to Elsa at first as thrown
together business partners, but eventually as “just friends.” They can’t be
more than that—she’s a princess and he delivers ice. He’s a “Fixer Upper” as
another fun song suggests, but also shows, that so is she. . . she after all is
“engaged” so someone she met at a party on the same day.
Anna
finally makes it to Elsa’s castle and asks her to stop the perpetual winter.
Elsa doesn’t know how, so refuses. She’s saddened because the illusion that she
can be free in her isolation is destroyed. She accidently again, mirroring the
accident in the beginning of the movie, strikes out and this time wounds Anna
in the heart. Then Elsa chases her and Christophe off by creating a snow
monster.
The
craziness of these events continues with a steady stream of action as the
pieces unwind. Hans leads an army that catches and imprisons Elsa. Anna’s heart
is freezing, and she will die if she isn’t saved by an act of true love. They
of course think the only act of true love is a kiss from her true love, which
must be Hans (it isn’t). Christophe leads her back to Arendelle, delivers her
to Hans safely. Hans reveals his true self and true intentions of wishing to
take over Arendelle, and his plans to kill both sisters.
Long
story short, Anna gives her own life to save Elsa. Sacrificial love is the
answer to how to reverse the perpetual winter. Sacrificial love is the missing
secret to how to control Elsa’s powers. Sacrificial love stops the freezing of
Anna’s own heart. Sacrificial love restores the sisters together once more in
friendship. Sacrificial love helps the people to love and understand Elsa,
rather than fear her. Sacrificial love is shown from Christophe towards Anna,
giving her to Hans, thinking of her rather than himself. Sacrificial love is even
shown by Olaf the snowman as he uses a fire to thaw Anna's freezing heart. Sacrificial
love solves all the problems of the world. Happily ever after. . . messy. . .
facing fear. . . changed. . . but happy. . . actualization of self and purpose.
It may not be your definition of Happiness, but think with your heart and not your head, and you will
know it to be the only true definition.
The movie is loosely based on Hans Christian Andersen's fairy tale, "The Snow Queen." That story is about returning to the innocence of youth in the way we see the world, to see the world with the faith of a child. He writes at the close of the story:
The grandmother sat in God’s bright sunshine, and she read aloud from the Bible, “Except ye become as little children, ye shall in no wise enter into the kingdom of God.” And Kay and Gerda looked into each other’s eyes, and all at once understood the words of the old song,
The movie is loosely based on Hans Christian Andersen's fairy tale, "The Snow Queen." That story is about returning to the innocence of youth in the way we see the world, to see the world with the faith of a child. He writes at the close of the story:
The grandmother sat in God’s bright sunshine, and she read aloud from the Bible, “Except ye become as little children, ye shall in no wise enter into the kingdom of God.” And Kay and Gerda looked into each other’s eyes, and all at once understood the words of the old song,
“Roses bloom and cease to be,
But we shall the Christ-child see.”
But we shall the Christ-child see.”
If
Christianity is about salvation, and salvation is about correcting Sin, and
Christ’s sacrifice does exactly that, the Gospel story is a perfect mirror to
this story. We each have power, like Elsa, it is within us, and perfect. We
need to find out what it is, not for ourselves, but so we can share it to the
world. The enemy to that actualization is fear. Faith then is the remedy. We need
to believe, as Jesus teaches us and shows us through his own act of sacrificial
love, that God is in control, loves us, has created us each with the purpose to
love, to share the gifts he gave us to the perfecting goodness of the world, not
to our perspective, but to the creator’s perfect perspective, complete, whole,
eternal, and true. We can live not in fear, but in love, the only happily ever
after. It’s another way of saying:
Our father,
Which art in heaven,
Hallowed be thy name, (We know You are)
Thy kingdom come, (We know it will)
Thy Will be done, (We know it will be)
On earth as it is in heaven, (Full perfect perspective includes both.
. . all)
Give us this day our daily bread (God will don’t fear)
Forgive our debts, (We have them, can’t
escape from them, but God made us)
As we forgive our debtors (Yeah, everybody else too)
Lead us not into temptation (Help us from the illusions)
But deliver us from evil (Even or especially within
ourselves)
For thine is the kingdom (Not ours)
And the power and the glory (Yes Yours not ours)
Forever (Happy ever after)
Amen. (May it be so!)
If
you haven’t seen it, go see it. It is the best Christmas sermon you will hear
this year, or come see us at Gordonsville Presbyterian Church. . . for some
almost as good (Wink)!
God
Bless. . .
Rev.
Peter T. Atkinson
No comments:
Post a Comment